Question of the day · 12 November 2026Permanent link to this question
CML vs. SML: Pricing Individual Assets and Risk Measures
- LevelCFA Level ISee similar
- TopicPortfolio ManagementSee similar
- SubtopicCML VS SML
- DifficultyMediumTwo or three stepsSee similar
- Published
FIP-CFA-L1-PM-002
An equity analyst is evaluating an individual equity security, Stock X, which is not part of a perfectly diversified portfolio. The analyst gathers the following market data:
| Description | Value |
|---|---|
| Risk-Free Rate () | 4.0% |
| Market Expected Return () | 10.0% |
| Market Standard Deviation () | 15.0% |
| Stock X Beta () | 1.2 |
| Stock X Standard Deviation () | 25.0% |
If the analyst mistakenly calculates the required rate of return using the Capital Market Line (CML) equation instead of the appropriate Security Market Line (SML) equation, the calculated required return will be closest to:
Correct answer: A. 2.8% too high.
Why A is correct
Step 1: Identify the correct model for an individual asset. The SML prices only systematic risk () and is the correct model for individual, non-diversified assets.
Step 2: Calculate the correct required return using the SML..
Step 3: Calculate the mistakenly applied required return using the CML (which improperly attempts to price total risk for a single asset)..
Step 4: Calculate the magnitude and direction of the error.. Because the CML calculates 14.0%, it is 2.8% too high.
Why B is incorrect
2.8% is correct, but misinterprets the direction. The CML applies a risk premium to the asset's idiosyncratic (unsystematic) risk, artificially inflating the required return
Why C is incorrect
This assumes the CML and SML yield the same required return. This is only true for perfectly diversified portfolios lying precisely on the efficient frontier
Common exam trap
Candidates often forget that the Capital Market Line uses total risk (standard deviation) and is valid only for perfectly well-diversified portfolios. The Security Market Line uses systematic risk (beta) and must be used for individual securities.
1-on-1 CFA® Level I coaching in Abu Dhabi or online across the UAE, AED 150 / hour
Challenge a friend
Get tomorrow’s question
MAWritten by Muhammad Ahmed RazaLead Instructor · CFA® & FRM®