PP&E Impairment: The IFRS vs. US GAAP Divergence Trap
- LevelCFA Level ISee similar
- TopicFinancial Statement AnalysisSee similar
- SubtopicLONG-LIVED ASSETS
- DifficultyHardSeveral steps or a common exam trapSee similar
- Published
FIP-CFA-L1-FSA-002
An equity analyst is evaluating a specialized piece of manufacturing equipment for year-end impairment. The equipment has the following financial metrics:
| Description | Amount |
|---|---|
| Carrying Value | $40,000 |
| Undiscounted Expected Future Cash Flows | $41,000 |
| Present Value of Expected Future Cash Flows (Value in Use) | $36,000 |
| Fair Value | $37,000 |
| Costs to Sell | $2,000 |
Based on this data, the impairment loss recognized under US GAAP and IFRS, respectively, is closest to:
Correct answer: A. US GAAP: $0 ; IFRS: $4,000
Why A is correct
Step 1: Test for US GAAP impairment (The Recoverability Test). Compare the Carrying Value ($40,000) to the Undiscounted Expected Future Cash Flows ($41,000).
Step 2: Because $40,000 is less than $41,000, the asset is NOT impaired under US GAAP. The US GAAP impairment loss is $0.
Step 3: Test for IFRS impairment. First, determine the Recoverable Amount.
Step 4: Calculate Fair Value less costs to sell ($37,000 - $2,000 = $35,000). Compare this to the Value in Use ($36,000). The Recoverable Amount is the higher of the two: $36,000.
Step 5: Calculate the IFRS impairment loss. Carrying Value ($40,000) - Recoverable Amount ($36,000) = $4,000.
Why B is incorrect
This completely skips US GAAP Step 1 and incorrectly calculates the loss directly as CV - FV ($40,000 - $37,000 = $3,000). For IFRS, it incorrectly uses Fair Value less costs to sell ($35,000) as the Recoverable Amount instead of the higher Value in Use, leading to a $5,000 loss.
Common exam trap
- Skipping the US GAAP "Step 1 Recoverability Test" (undiscounted cash flows) and jumping straight to calculating the loss based on fair value or discounted cash flows.
- Under IFRS candidate offen forget to consider when Value in use given using max(selling price - cost of seeling), value in use), and directly used the min(carry value, NRV)
1-on-1 CFA® Level I coaching in Abu Dhabi or online across the UAE, AED 150 / hour
Challenge a friend
Get tomorrow’s question
MAWritten by Muhammad Ahmed RazaLead Instructor · CFA® & FRM®